The Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) ruling on indirect taxes on capital raising (Case C-837/24)

08 June 2026 – need2know

1. The Judgment at a Glance

On 4 June 2026, the CJEU in Case C-837/24 (Nova Iberomoldes) ruled that Council Directive 2008/7/EC prohibits national indirect taxes on corporate restructurings where capital is paid up via shareholdings in property-owning companies.

2. Background and Facts of the Case

  • Transaction: A Portuguese company was formed via non-cash contributions of shares, including holdings in companies with real estate.
  • Tax Issue: Portuguese authorities imposed a real estate transfer tax (IMT) because the share acquisition was legally treated as a transfer of the underlying property.
  • Court’s Assessment: The CJEU ruled that this is a restructuring operation under Directive 2008/7/EC, meaning it is exempt from indirect taxes. The exception for direct property transfers does not apply, and anti-abuse provisions cannot justify taxing this transaction.

3. Impact on the Legal Situation in Austria

The ruling binds all EU Member States, directly impacting the Austrian Real Estate Transfer Tax Act (Grunderwerbsteuergesetz – GrEStG).

3.1 The Austrian RETT regime

Under the “new” Austrian RETT regime (since 1 July 2025), share transfer transactions may trigger Austrian real estate transfer tax if at least 75% of the shares in a corporation owning Austrian real estate

  • are directly transferred to new shareholders within 7 years (change of direct shareholder structure) or
  • are directly or indirectly concentrated in one hand (so called acquisition of unified shares or share unification).

In these cases, Austrian RETT amounts to 0.5% of a specific RETT tax base (or 3.5% of the fair market value in certain situations).

3.2 Consequences of Case C-837/24

  1. Directive Precedence: The CJEU’s broad interpretation indicates that share-based restructurings cannot be burdened by Austrian RETT via “economic transfer” theories (if relevant, this could be backed by a ruling to be obtained from the Austrian tax authorities).
  2. Defensive Strategy: Taxpayers can leverage this ruling to contest Austrian RETT assessments on qualified restructurings.
  3. Appeals: Recent Austrian assessments regarding qualifying restructuring contributions should be reviewed for appeal opportunities.

 

Authors:
Kornelia Wittmann
Nicolas Wolski

Practice group:
Tax

The summary (as a PDF).

© 2026 bpv Hügel Rechtsanwälte

Our use of cookies

We use necessary and functionality cookies to make our site work. We only use analytics cookies to improve our website if you enable them. By using this tool for individual settings of the cookies, we will send a cookie to your device to remember your preferences.

For more detailed information about the cookies we use, see our Cookies Policy.

Necessary Cookies Necessary cookies enable core functionality such as security, network management, and accessibility. You may disable these by changing your browser settings, but this may affect the website functions.

Functionality Cookies

Functionality cookies allow users to customise how a website looks for them: they can remember usernames, language preferences and regions. We use functionality cookies for storing your user preferences and remembering if you have been to the site before so that messages intended for first-time users are not displayed to you. These cookies do not collect information about you that could be used for marketing purposes and do not remember where you have been on the Internet.

You may disable these cookies with the button, but you should be aware that any preferences will be lost and you will have to make them again on your next visit. It is also possible that the website will not work properly or you will lose some functionality.

Analytics cookies (including US providers)

"Web analytics cookies" collect aggregated information about user behaviour to improve our website. We would like to use such cookies from Google Analytics to improve our website by collecting and evaluating information about the use of our website. The provider of Google Analytics is Google LLC, which is based in the USA. The USA is not certified by the European Court of Justice as having an adequate level of data protection. In particular, there is a risk that your data may be accessed by US authorities for control and monitoring purposes and that no effective legal remedies are available against this. By activating the button under "Web analytics cookies (including from US providers)", you agree that we may set these cookies and that you also agree to the transfer of data to the USA. You can revoke your consent at any time via the cookie settings on our website.